CURRENT ISSUE
BACK ISSUES
SUBSCRIBE
ADVERTISE
ABOUT JCEHP
FOR AUTHORS
JCEHP AWARD
SEARCH
|
|
Volume 28 (1)
Volume 28, Issue 1, Winter 2008
J Contin Educ Health Prof 2008; 28(1)
FOUNDATIONS OF CONTINUING EDUCATION
Self-Monitoring in Clinical Practice: A Challenge for Medical Educators
Epstein RM, Siegel DJ, Silberman J
A b s t r a c t
Recent literature has described how the capacity for concurrent self-assessment—ongoing moment-to-moment
self-monitoring—is an important component of the professional competence of physicians. Self-monitoring refers
to the ability to notice our own actions, curiosity to examine the effects of those actions, and willingness to use
those observations to improve behavior and thinking in the future. Self-monitoring allows for the early recognition
of cognitive biases, technical errors, and emotional reactions and may facilitate self-correction and development
of therapeutic relationships. Cognitive neuroscience has begun to explore the brain functions associated with
self-monitoring, and the structural and functional changes that occur during mental training to improve attentiveness,
curiosity, and presence. This training involves cultivating habits of mind such as experiencing information as
novel, thinking of “facts” as conditional, seeing situations from multiple perspectives, suspending categorization
and judgment, and engaging in self-questioning. The resulting awareness is referred to as mindfulness and the
associated moment-to-moment self-monitoring as mindful practice—in contrast to being on “automatic pilot” or
“mindless” in one’s behavior. This article is a preliminary exploration into the intersection of educational assessment,
cognitive neuroscience, and mindful practice, with the hope of promoting ways of improving clinicians’
capacity to self-monitor during clinical practice, and, by extension, improve the quality of care that they deliver.
Lessons for Practice
- Self-monitoring is an aspect of selfassessment
that may contribute to quality
of care and reduction in errors.
- Self-monitoring depends on the ability to
regulate attention, maintain curiosity, and
be flexible during daily work, especially
when under stress and multitasking.
- Self-deception, denial, and delusion are
common barriers to self-assessment and
self-monitoring.
- Self-monitoring can be improved by cultivating
the “observing self”: adopting a “beginner’s
mind,” seeing “facts” as conditional,
considering multiple perspectives, suspending
categorization and judgment, and developing
habits of self-questioning.
|