CURRENT ISSUE
BACK ISSUES
SUBSCRIBE
ADVERTISE
ABOUT JCEHP
FOR AUTHORS
JCEHP AWARD
SEARCH
(Members only) FULL-TEXT
|
|
Volume 21 (4)
Volume 21, Issue 4, Fall 2001
J Contin Educ Health Prof 2001; 21(4):198-202
ISSUES IN RESEARCH
Pedigrees, Propaganda, and Paranoia: Family Studies in a Historical Context
Paul A. Lombardo, PhD, JD
A b s t r a c t
This article reviews the uses of family studies carried out in the early 20th century under the banner of eugenics, a companion discipline to early genetics. It explores how, in an attempt to analyze and quantify purportedly biologic bases of social problems, the eugenicists constructed pedigree charts of notoriously "defective" families. Investigation of individuals with suspect traits formed the basis for instruction of field workers who linked those traits to larger groups. The resulting eugenic family studies provided a "scientific" face for a popular hereditarian mythology that claimed to explain all social failure in systematic terms. The eugenicists were successful in fueling public fear about the growing "army of idiots and imbeciles" graphically depicted in their pedigree charts. Their success was the result of a finely crafted educational program—propaganda that reduced science to simplistic terms. The tendency to oversimplify concepts of genetic causation and the rush to amplify the significance of research findings through the popular media is also apparent today. What begins as publicity has the potential to be transformed into propaganda. Although many in the scientific community are understandably reluctant to revisit the abuses of the past, that community must confront the history of eugenics as a necessary antidote to the genetic hype that surrounds us.
MeSH Terms: Bioethics; Eugenics; Genetic Predisposition to Disease; History of Medicine, 19th Cent.; History of Medicine, 20th Cent.; Human Experimentation; Pedigree; Propaganda; Research Social Problems; Sterilization, Involuntary
Publication Type: Review; Historical Article
|