CURRENT ISSUE
BACK ISSUES
SUBSCRIBE
ADVERTISE
ABOUT JCEHP
FOR AUTHORS
JCEHP AWARD
SEARCH
|
|
Volume 17 (3)
Volume 17, Issue 3, Summer 1997
J Contin Educ Health Prof 1997; 17(3):141-147
ORIGINAL ARTICLES
Workshop versus Lecture in CME: Does Physician Learning Method Preference Make a Difference?
Yves Lacoursière, CME "Intern"
Linda Snell, MD, FRCPC
Jacqueline McClaran, BSc, MD, FCFP(C)
Eliane Duarte-Franco, MD, MPH
A b s t r a c t
Is learning enhanced when the continuing medical education (CME) intervention
corresponds to the physician’s preferred learning method? Eighty-eight primary care community-
based physicians were involved in this study. Each physician attended one of three
2-day CME programs based on a needs assessment of community-based primary care physicians.
Each program consisted of both plenary lectures and workshops. Learning method
preference and demographic profile were captured by an individual electronic touch pad that
allowed each physician’s responses to be uniquely identified by the system. A pre- and post-test
for each workshop and each lecture was carried out. Responses were noted via touch pad.
Mean test score improvement occurred for each intervention and was statistically significant
for 12 of 14 interventions. Mean test score improvements for workshops and for lectures were
not different. Mean test score improvements were not affected by physician learning method
preference. These results are not explained by gender, year of graduation, or rural/urban differences
of physicians. Contrary to our hypothesis, our data suggest that physicians do not
necessarily learn more when the type of CME intervention is concordant with their preferred
learning methods. Further, workshops, small groups, and other interactive CME activities
may not always be more effective than didactic methods such as lectures. Further study is warranted.
In the meantime, it may be more efficient for CME teachers and providers to use
methods with which they are comfortable or that they consider more appropriate to the content.
Keywords: Continuing Medical Education; Didactic versus Interactive; Electronic
Touch Pad; Intervention Study; Knowledge Outcome; Lecture versus Workshop; Multiple Choice
Questionnaire; Physician Learning Method Preference; Post-Test; Pretest
|